Windows Event ID 5168: SPN check for SMB/SMB2 failed
Written when the SPN check for SMB/SMB2 fails. It indicates that the SPN validation required by the server was not satisfied and can be a sign of an NTLM relay attack.
Overview
The subcategory is Audit File Share. It is generated when the SPN (Service Principal Name) check during an SMB/SMB2 connection fails. It often happens when the server sets the Group Policy “Microsoft network server: Server SPN target name validation level” to “Required from client” while the client connects with NTLMv1 or LM. An SPN is sent to the server, and can be validated, only when NTLMv2 or Kerberos is used.
How it is triggered
- When, in an SMB connection, the presented SPN does not match or no SPN is sent (for example, a connection using NTLMv1/LM).
- Besides configuration inconsistency, it can occur in attacks involving relaying.
Security review points
- An SPN check failure can be a sign of an
NTLM relay attack(relaying authentication to another server to access by impersonation). SPN validation is one of the relay defenses, and if its failures concentrate on a specific source or server, investigate. - Correlate with network logon 4624 (Type 3, NTLM) and NTLM validation 4776 to track authentication flows suspected of relaying.
Notes for log review
- It also occurs from configuration inconsistency (SPN registration mistakes, etc.). Separate attack from configuration-induced by source, target server, and frequency.
- Note bursts of SPN check failures against a specific server.
MITRE ATT&CK mapping
| Technique | Tactic | What this event shows |
|---|---|---|
| T1557.001 Name Resolution Poisoning and SMB Relay | Credential Access, Collection | SMB authentication failing on an SPN mismatch indicates NTLM relay |
Mapping as of ATT&CK v19.2. To search by technique, see the ATT&CK reverse lookup.
Key fields
| Field | Meaning |
|---|---|
SPN Name / Error Code | The SPN that failed validation and the error code |
Server Names / Configured Names / IP Addresses | The names the server accepts, the configured names, and IP addresses |
Glossary
- NTLM relay attack — an attack that forwards stolen/relayed authentication to another server to access by impersonating the victim. Mitigated by SMB signing and SPN target name validation.